• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Squire's Italian Restaurant

At Squire's Italian Restaurant, a cherished gem in Dundalk, MD, we invite you to savor authentic Italian cuisine infused with local charm. With a history spanning decades, our establishment offers a welcoming atmosphere perfect for family dinners and gatherings. Diners rave about our signature dishes, especially the seafood pizza, where fresh crab and shrimp meet a perfectly balanced savory sauce. Our menu caters to all tastes, from hearty meat sauce pizzas to classic Chicken Parmesan. Enjoy excellent service, spacious seating, and a cozy ambiance as you indulge in our quality fare. Experience Squire's, where every meal feels like home.

Squire's Italian Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings

Tarsha S.
Tarsha S.

Wow.!! Very nice establishment. I only had pizza but the pizza was perfectly made and the flavors were delicious. I will be back to try other items off the menu and to update this review.

Krystal H.
Krystal H.

Been loving Squires for years. Meat sauce pizza is my go to. Good service too. I like their cream of crab and my son loves the Chicken Parmesan

Brian F.
Brian F.

Been enjoying squires since childhood . Excellent pizza , diverse menus, consistent quality and here service

Brad R.
Brad R.

TLDR: A Baltimore County Italian staple. Perfect for family dinners and get togethers. Don't miss the seafood pizza! Vibe: 5/5. Situated right on the City/County line in Dundalk, Squire's has been in the Italian food game for decades. The restaurant is a sprawling complex, complete with ample private lot parking and seating arrangements to accommodate both groups large and small. Accessibility is also very easy, making this a perfect option for quick lunches and last minute to go orders. Inside, the restaurant shows it's age, but in a nice way (think like a fine patina). Everything has been maintained, with clean bathrooms and dining surfaces throughout the place. Overall, Squire's exudes a "homey" atmosphere. Service: 5/5. The waitstaff at Squires were fantastic from start to finish. My table of 5 was seated immediately by the hostess for our 6pm Friday dinner (restaurant was busy). Our waitress came over immediately and began taking drink orders. Both food and drinks came out very quickly after ordering and we never had a problem with refills. Extra brownie points for providing a pitcher of iced tea without us asking for some extra thirsty members of the table. Food: 5/5. Simple yet tasty American Italian fare with some Maryland twists. For dinner, we ordered the seafood pizza, buffalo pizza, calamari and a few cups of cream of crab and 50/50 (cream and crab and MD Crab). The soups were fantastic, with backfin lump clusters gracing the top of each cup. The calamari was perfectly fried and generous in portion size. But the pièce de résistance was certainly the pizza. Squire's is notable for their crispy yet hearty pies, which are thicker than thin crust/ NYC style but much thinner than sicilian. Both the buffalo and seafood pizza were perfectly baked to a golden brown and generous in toppings. If we had to pick a favorite, the seafood pie would take best in show, as the delicate flavors of the shrimp and crab toppings played wonderfully with the spicy seafood based red sauce and mozz cheese. Overall, Squire's is a solid go to pick for some honest, Maryland Italian eats!

Ahra J.
Ahra J.

I haven't been to Squires in about 2 years but visited tonight for dinner with family and it was a great experience! First the service was excellent! Our server was attentive and she checked in on us periodically but not too much. She was also quick with greeting us, bringing us our drinks and food. Given it was a Friday night, families started to slow trickle in but the restaurant is large so it can seat many people without having to wait too long. We ordered crab soup, buffalo pizza and seafood pizza. The soup was THICKKK. I personally didn't like the texture as I would have preferred a more liquid consistency. However, I did appreciate the lump crab meat on top! I think it more than made up for the consistency. The buffalo pizza lacked the buffalo sauce tang. Because of that, it tasted a little bland. I can't say I would recommend or maybe ask for more sauce to round out the flavor. The seafood pizza though was the star! It had pieces of crab and shrimp and the red sauce was savory and well balanced. I would highly recommend this pizza! There is also a large parking lot with handicap spots, wheelchair ramp, and carry out parking spots.

Kristel L.
Kristel L.

Food is always good and had wonderful service as well. The meat filled manicotti is hands down the best I have ever eaten. The meat sauce and meatballs are also delicious. Oh and that peanut butter pie- wow!

Location

Welcome to Squire's Italian Restaurant, a cherished gem nestled in Dundalk, Maryland, where authentic Italian cuisine meets a warm, inviting atmosphere. With a legacy built over decades, Squire's has cemented its place as a favorite for both locals and visitors, offering a delightful array of dishes that celebrate the best of Italian flavors with an unmistakable Maryland twist.

Located at 6723 Holabird Ave, Squire's is easily accessible and ideal for various occasions—be it a family dinner, a casual lunch, or a cozy get-together with friends. The extensive parking and wheelchair accessibility ensure that everyone can enjoy a meal here. With the convenience of reservations, delivery, and takeout options, Squire's caters to the needs of every guest, making it the perfect spot for any dining preference.

Why Squire's Stands Out

  • Casual Vibe: The ambiance is relaxed, with moderate noise levels that create a friendly, homey atmosphere.
  • Welcoming Service: Consistently praised for attentive and friendly staff who enhance the dining experience from start to finish.
  • Diverse Menu: While the menu features classic Italian staples, it also boasts unique Maryland specialties that set it apart.
  • Perfect for Groups: The spacious setting accommodates families and large gatherings comfortably.

Highlights of the Menu:

  • Seafood Pizza: A favorite among regulars, this dish features a savory red sauce topped with fresh shrimp and crab, perfectly baked for a delightful crunch.
  • Buffalo Pizza: While some may find it needs a bit more sauce, it appeals to those looking for a twist on a classic.
  • Crab Soup: Rich in lump crab meat, this hearty soup can surprise with its thick consistency, making it a comforting starter.

Every plate at Squire's reflects quality and consistency, with dishes meticulously prepared to satisfy both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike. Many guests return for the undeniable allure of the meat sauce pizza or the delightful cream of crab, showcasing the restaurant's knack for marrying Italian classics with local flavors.

As Tarsha S. noted, "the pizza was perfectly made and the flavors were delicious," highlighting the attention to detail that Squire's prides itself on. Whether you're savoring a slice on-site or indulging in takeout, you’re in for a memorable meal.

So, why not gather your loved ones and visit Squire's Italian Restaurant? With a commitment to quality, a welcoming environment, and a menu that delights, it's an Italian dining experience you won't want to miss. Make sure to stop by for their Happy Hour specials or take advantage of their catering services for your next event. Dive into the tastes of Italy right in the heart of Dundalk—you won’t be disappointed!